BC SUPREME COURT
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

COMMERCIAL 1999

• Henry et al v. Stockhouse Media Corporation et al
• Manion v. Western Pulp Limited Partnership et al
• Recchia v. Co-operators Life Insurance Company et al
• Rosbergen v. Westminster Traders Ltd. et al.
• Parakin v. Bandali Medical Services Inc.
• Kosky v. Quadra Credit Union
• Shinn v. TBC Teletheatre BC
• Henderson Land Holdings (Canada) Ltd. v. Micron Construction Ltd.
• Hoven v. C.M. Oliver & Co. Ltd.
• Mavin v. Zellers Ltd.
• Vic Van Isle Construction Ltd. v. Lomenda & Hopfner
• Ray's Roofing (1990) Ltd. v. E &D Ventures Ltd.
• Innovent Development Corp. v. Lim
• D.E. Installations Ltd. v. D.G.S. Construction Co.
• Northwest Capital Corp. v. E.C.R.A.
• Ducharme v. England
• Service Corp. International (Canada) Inc. v. Burnaby (City of)
• Neudorf v. Nettwerk Productions Ltd.
• Neudorf v. Nettwerk Productions Ltd.
• Lasik Vision Canada Ltd. v. TLC Vancouver Optometric Group Inc.
• Timberwest Forest Ltd. v. British Columbia
• Weeks v. JJM Construction Ltd. et al.
• Ferguson et al. v. Grampian Holdings Ltd.
• Culos Development Corporation v. High Street Corporation Ltd.
• Pasnak et al. v. Chura et al.
• Bankruptcies of Taylor Ventures Inc. et al.
• Lavery v. A.M.P.M. Service Ltd.
• TVC Techventures Corp. et al. v. Weiss
• Island Bridge and Piling Contracting Ltd. v. Cranemaster Sales Ltd.
• In the Matter of United Used Auto & Truck Parts Ltd.
• Couiyk v. Couiyk
• Boulton v. Frandel Frames Ltd.
• Wah Kwong Enterprises Ltd. v. New Westminster
• Ono v. Kerr
• Pacific Northwest Herb Corp. v. Thompson
• Bankruptcy of ASI Acoustical Supplies Inc.
• Wharton v. Tom Harris Chevrolet Oldsmobile Cadillac Ltd. et al.
• Priority Building Services Ltd. v. Ali
• J.S. McMillan Fisheries Ltd. v. Trico Refrigeration Limited
• Reform Party of Canada v. Western Union Insurance Company
• Tobem Projects Ltd. v. 453259 B.C. Ltd.
• Cantelon v. Industrial Wood and Allied Workers of Canada et al.
• Northwood Inc. v. Forest Practices Board
• CRC Creditor Resources Canada Limited v. Kasdorf
• Proform Projects Inc. v. Lessard Project Management and Construction Inc. et al.
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Michael Volker Stoldt
• In Bankruptcy of Fred Walls & Son Holdings Limited
• Ganderton v. Marzen Artistic Aluminum Ltd. et al.
• Kalicum Drilling Ltd. v. Orca Estates Ltd.
• Quality Concrete Formwork Ltd. v. Vanbots Construction Corporation et al.
• Envirocare Industries Ltd. v. Kaethler et al.
• Bankruptcy of Jon Edward Los
• Bank of Montreal v. Kimberley Brewing Co. Ltd. et al.
• Bankruptcy of Lawrence Steve Kostiuk
• Norrish v. Unum Life Insurance of America
• Ebco Industries Ltd. v. Kaltech Manufacturing Ltd. et al.
• D D & D Drillers Ltd. v. Robertson et al.
• Tracy v. Wobick et al.
• Seow v. ESI Enterprises Inc.
• Matusiak v. BC & Yukon Territory Building & Trades Council
• Vancouver Industrial Electric v. Leone Industries
• Macdonald v. Wajax Industries Ltd.
• JDM Capital v. Smith et al
• Degelder Construction v. Westfair Properties
• Ahamed v. Ahamed
• Sehra v. Murgai
• Elbee Development Corp. v. A & D Masonry
• Curtin v. Blewett
• Donaldson v. MacInnes
• Punjab Foods Centre Ltd. v. Baillie et al.
• Canaccord Capital Corporation v. Clough
• Willemse v. Co-Operators General Insurance Company
• Ebco Industries v. Kaltech Manufacturing Ltd.
• ITMB Publishing v. Weller Cartographic Services Ltd.
• New Home Warranty of BC v. Ashcroft
• Waddell v. Cintas Corp.
• Mosher v. Epic Energy et al
• Gujral v. President's Corporate Group Inc. et al.
• J.K. Expression Jewellery Inc. v. Gerling Global General Insurance Company et al.
• Las Vegas Casino v. Starnet Communications International Inc.
• Bankruptcy of Canadian Bioconcepts
• Huurman v. Montgomery
• Bower et al. v. Cominco et al.
• West Shore Constructors Limited v. Sandspit Habour Society et al.
• Ebco Industries Ltd. v. 490870 BC Ltd.
• Kubota Canada Ltd. v. Cougar Pacific Equipment Ltd. et al.
• Molsen et al. v. McCallum et al.
• Bell v. Bell
• Birchall v. Canadian Helicopter Limited
• The Bank of Nova Scotia v. Royal Bank of Canada
• Coastal Web Press Inc. v. Common Ground Publishing Corp.
• CIBC Mortgage Corp. v. Pender et al.
• Ranzau et al. v. 80451 Holdings Ltd. et al.
• Jost v. Western Railco Products Ltd. et al.
• Bankruptcy of Westar Mining Ltd.
• Royal Bank of Canada v. Mt. Baker Auto Body Ltd. et al.
• Re:   Simon Wei Kitnikone, A Bankrupt
• Eron Mortgage Corporation et al. v. Eron Mortgage Corporation et al.
• Accredit Mortgage Ltd. v. Grealy et al.
• D. Dillman Enterprises Ltd. v. Charel Holdings Ltd.
• Bankruptcy of Lawrence Steve Kostiuk
• Mac and Mac Power Washing Co. Ltd. v. Meyer Industrial Services Ltd. et al.
• Instant Laws Turf Farm (1994) Ltd. v. B&D Landscaping and Maintenance Service Ltd. et al.
• Bradley v. Bradley et al.
• Smart v. McCall Pontiac Buick Ltd. et al.
• Pacific National Securities Inc. v. Drake Capital Securities Inc. et al.
• Pan Pacific Specialities Ltd. v. Shangong Machinery and Equipment I/E Corp. et al.
• Clan Glass & Metals Ltd. v. Ledcor Industries Ltd. et al.
• Morrison v. Cormier Vegetation Control Ltd. et al.
• Cragg v. Meridian Yacht Sales Ltd.
• Derlago v. White
• Leong v. Princess Investments Ltd.
• R.W. Anderson Contracting Ltd. v. Stambulic Bros. Construction Ltd. et al.
• Burgess Agri Supplies Ltd. v. Houle et al.
• In Bankruptcy In The Matter of the Proposal of New Home Warranty of B.C. Inc.
• Grinnell Supply Sales Co. v. Heger Contracting Ltd. et al.
• Carinci et al. v. Adams
• Gibbons et al. v. Tarapaski
• Fire Clay Minerals Inc. v. Clark, Wilson et al.
• Alford et al v. A.G. Canada et al
• 360788 B.C. Ltd. v. 304983 B.C. Ltd.
• Midland Pacific Properties Corp. & Chan
• Bankruptcy of Oliver
• Fred Walls & Sons in Bankruptcy
• Weaver v. Insystems Technologies Inc.
• St. Dennis v. I.C.B.C.
• Grafton v. Hongkong Bank of Canada
• Johnstone v. Island Scales Ltd.
• Slocan Forest Products Ltd. et al. v. HMTQ et al.
• CRS Forestal et al. v. RBC Dominion Securities Inc. et al.
• Kwick Clean and Green Ltd. et al. v. Ledingham et al.
• Clark v. Atlas Power Sweeping Ltd.
• McCabe v. Simon Fraser Campus Radio Society
• Gold Key Pontiac Buick (1984) Ltd. v. BDO Dunwoody Limited et al.
• Whitevalley Log Homes Ltd. v. Valley First Insurance Services Ltd. et al.
• Banktuptcies of James Blair Down et al.
• Hamm et al. v. Goodleaf Northern et al.
• The Bankruputcies of James Blair Down et al.
• Bishop v. Dac et al.
• Hodder Construction (1993) Ltd. v. Pellizzon
• Samas Investments v. Pattison et al.
• Genessee Enterprises Ltd. v. Abou-Rached et al.
• YMCF Inc. v. Snow et al
• Kowasch v. Desolation Resort Ltd.
• Longley v. HMTQ
• Spencehill Holdings Ltd. v. Petro-Canada et al.
• Abel v. Burke
• TNL Paving Ltd. v. HMTQ
• Arnott v. Tundra Steel Products
• Dr. Kofsky Inc. v. Zurich Insurance Co.
• Kostiuk, In Bankruptcy
• Cantelon v. International Wood and Allied Workers of Canada, Local 1-71
• Toth v. Oak Lane Enterprises
• J.W. Price Construction Ltd. v. Elan Construction Ltd.
• Niemyt v. Commertec Capital Corp.
• Palmieri v. A.C. Paving Company Ltd. et al.
• Canadian Helicopters Limited v. Interpac Forest Products Ltd. et al.
• Dec Finance Inc. v. Wrappaninis Foods Ltd. et al.
• Kirkham et al. v. Vandegoede et al.
• Teves v. T.T.M. Building Maintenance et al.
• Bondi v. Geographics Marketing Canada Ltd.
• Springmann v. J.W. Bison Ranch Ltd. et al.
• Smith v. Peace Arch Community Service
• Martens et al. v. Acheson et al.
• Farrell Estates Ltd. v. Prominent Realty Group Inc. et al.
• Seaboard Life Insurance Company v. Bank of Montreal et al.
• North Ridge Fishing Ltd. et al. v. The Owners & All Others Interested int he Ship "Prosperity" et al.
• Flintoff v. Trimex Marketing Inc.
• Beach v. Ikon Office Solutions Inc.
• RDA Film Distribution Inc. et al. v. B.C. Trade Development Corp.
• Business Development Bank of Canada v. E & B Construction Ltd. et al.
• Stro-Built Wall and Ceiling Inc. v. Civil Construction Co. Ltd. et al.
• Niemyt v. Commertec Capital Corp. et al.
• Raphael et al. v. Unum Life Insurance Company of America
• Martin v. Amercian International Assurance Life Company Ltd. et al.
• Buildworks Construction Inc. v. Ng
• Busnex Business Exchange Ltd. v. Creston Builders Supply Ltd.
• HTN Engineering Ltd. v. Raymond Chan Engineering Ltd.
• Chan v. Chin Wing Chun Tong Society of Canada
• Denmar Equipment Rentals Ltd. v. Land Craft Ventures Ltd.
• Westminster Savings Credit Union v. Delta Shake & Shingle (1989) Ltd.
• Green Limits Contracting v. MacKenzie Redi-Mix
• GMAC Leasco Ltd. v. Stalker
• Canadian Northern Shield Insurance Co. v. Booth
• Westshore Terminals v. Sandwell Inc. et al
• Bankruptcy Proposal of BCS Technology Inc.
• Douglas Symes & Brissenden v. LSBC Captive Insurance Co.
• BC Enterprise Corp. v. Springhall
• Rhino Freight Systems v. McTaggart
• Sheehan v. BC Hydro & Power Authority
• Midwest Management (1987) Ltd. v. BC Gas Facility Ltd.
• Sauberli v. Gill et al.
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Warren Stacey Oliver
• Intra Land Corporation v. Northwood Food Corporation et al.
• Alexander J. Holdings Ltd. v. Delta Play Ltd. et al.
• Board of School Trustee of School District No. 39 v. Royal Oak Holdings Ltd.
• Chan v. Cheng
• Sohi et al. v. Khalsa Diwan Society et al.
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of William John Pulford
• Hayes Heli-Log Services Ltd. et al. v. Siller Bros. Inc.
• Rava Innovations Inc. v. International Parkside Products Inc. et al.
• In the Matter of Westar Mining Ltd.
• West Shore Ventures Ltd. v. K.P.N. Holding Ltd.
• Probek v. Konte
• Inskip v. Jacobson Ford Mercury Sales Ltd.
• Busnex Business Exchange v. Creston Builders Supply Ltd.
• Sparten Establishment v. International Telepresence (Canada) Inc.
• Sjerven v. Port Alberni Friendship Center
• Romanchuk v. The City of Revelstoke
• Bartholomew v. Electric Power Equipment Ltd. et al.
• Rossen et al. v. Kwong et al.
• Stefanuk v. Jeffrey
• Wednesday Enterprises Inc. v. Modern Building Cleaning Inc. et al.
• Havens v. John Watson Ltd.
• Beise v. Harwood & Harwood Construction
• Niagara Construction Contracting Ltd. v. Khayattein et al
• Gill et al. v. Khalsa Diwan Society
• Jersey Petroleum Inc. v. Tidelands Oil Corporation et al.
• Glendale v. Namgis Education Society
• Canadian Merchant Navy Veterans Association Incorporated et al. v. Macisaac et al.
• E.C.R.A. Elderly Citizen Recreation Association v. Loeppky Consulting Ltd.
• Golden Hill Ventures v. Kemess Mines Inc.
• Husband v. Labatt Brewing Co.
• Bellai v. B.C. Insurance Company et al.
• Grosvenor v. Streifel
• British Columbia Life & Casualty Company v. Meek
• Falls Creek Falling Contractors v. Pat Carson Bulldozing Ltd.
• Moroz v. Les Helicopteres Abitibi Ltee.
• Kropp et al. v. Swaneset Bay Golf Course Ltd.
• VCR Print Company Ltd. v. Jung et al.
• Spoor et al v. Nicholls
• HMTQ   v. Therrien et al.
• Patent Construction Systems et al. v. Greater Vancouver Sewerage and Drainage District et al.
• Johnson v. B.C. Securities Commission et al.
• Bockhold v. Lawson Lundell Lawson & McIntosh et al.
• Burdeny v. K & D Gourmet Baked Foods and Investments Inc. et al.
• Gajic v. Wolverton Securities Ltd. et al.
• Hide-Away Resort Ltd. v. Van Der Wal et al.
• Diamond Carpet Centre v. Parmar
• Sullco Inc. v. Cara Glen Estates Ltd.
• Larsen v. Airarms Fasteners & Industrial Ltd.
• Herold v. Marathan Development Inc. et al.
• Sall v. Canada Life Assurance Company
• Trumpeter Yukon Gold Inc. v. Omni Resources Inc.
• Stasiuk et al. v. West Kootenay Power Ltd. et al.
• Duggan v. Cowichan Family Life Assoc.
• Quantum Financial Services et al v. Yip et al
• Unisource Canada Ltd. v. Enterprise Paper Co. Ltd. et al
• Harmony Co-ordination Services Ltd. v. 542479 B.C. Ltd. et al
• Spoor et al v. Nicholls et al
• Scavo et al v. Dubnyk
• Pacific Northwest Contracting Ltd. v. Hou's Farm Holdings Ltd. et al
• Charles v. A&B Sound
• Alert Bay Credit Union v. Nimpkish Ventures Ltd.
• Niemyt v. Commertec Capital Corp et al
• Osborne et al v. Pavlick
• Mohabir v. Dvorak et al.
• Alder v. Dobie et al.
• Fame Construction Ltd. v. 430863 B.C. Ltd.
• Maryn v. Unum Life Insurance Company of America et al.
• William v. Lake Babine Indian Band et al.
• Family Insurance Group Limited et al. v. Sienema et al
• Lemay v. Kelowna Cabs (1981) Ltd.
• Bankruptcy of Taylor Ventures Ltd. et al.
• Clark v. Clark
• Pezzotti v. Zuliani et al.
• Halagan v. Reifel
• Regency Plymouth Chrysler Inc. v. ICBC
• Shenzhen City Luohu Industrial Development Company v. Yao et al.
• Chan et al. v. Chadha Construction & Investments Ltd. et al.
• Tait Mobile Radio Inc. v. Pacific Circuit Design Ltd. et al.
• 442246 B.C. Ltd. et al. v. 0909 Management Inc. et al.
• Beise v. Harwood et al.
• Royal Bank of Canada v. Tuxedo Transport Ltd.
• Yacht Harbour Pointe Development Corporation v. Architectura Waisman Dewar Grout Carter Inc. et al.
• British Columbia Medical Association v. Medical Services Commission et al.
• Baldwin v. Quinsam Coal Corporation
• Coates v. General Motors Acceptance Corporation of Canada Limited
• Old Country Rentals Ltd. v. Orv Coulter Construction Ltd. et al.
• Omnivalor Management Inc. v. Scott
• Koenigshofer v. Koenigshofer
• In the Matter of the Bankrupty of David Arthur Waller
• Greystone Capital Management Inc. v. Greystone Properties Ltd. et al.
• Fewings v. The Hills Health & Guest Ranch Ltd.
• Mohr v. The Paul Revere Life Insurance Company
• J.P. Metal Masters Inc. v. David Mitchell Co. Ltd. et al.
• Lecleir Bros. Contracting Ltd. v. Canoe Cove Marina Ltd.
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Dudley Kill & Sons Ltd.
• Joglia v. Aetna Life Insurance Company of Canada et al.
• Erfanifar v. Erfanifar
• The Plant Software Inc. v. 9123 Investments  et al.
• Suchy et al v. Zurich Insurance Co. et al
• Boutsakis et al v. Alexis House Cafe et al
• Tutt Bros. Transporation Ltd. v. Teamsters Local 213 et al.
• Canadian Glacier Beverage Corp. v. Barnes & Kissack Inc. et al.
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Lawrence Steve Kostiuk
• Goldleaf Northern (1991) Gold Fund Limited Partnership v. Wilcox et al.
• CIBC v. The Owners and All Other Interested in the Ship "Barkley Sound" et al.
• Valley Custom Jackhammer Service v. Prins Greenhouses 96 Ltd. et al.
• Phelps Appliances Ltd. v. Deloitte & Touche et al.
• J.P. Metal Masters Inc. v. Marbella Pacific Const. West Ltd.
• Eron Mortgage Corporation in its Capacity as Trustee et al. v. Eron Mortgage Corporation
• Westshore Terminals Ltd. v. HMTQ
• District of Squamish v. Great Pacific Pumice
• Woodruff v. Alloway et al.
• Eron Financial Services Limited et al. v. Biller et al.
• Hydro Fuels Inc. et al. v. Mid-Pacific Services Inc. et al.
• In the Matter of the Company Act and In the Matter of Salon Salon Hair Fashions Ltd.
• Jamison et al. v. Video Only, Inc.
• The Owners, Strata Plan No. VR 1720 v. Bart Development Ltd. et al.
• Reid v. The Mutual Life Assurance Company et al.
• Buck et al. v. Dale Miller Logging Ltd. et al.
• Ogden v. Award Realty Inc. et al.
• Balla et al. v. Fitch Research Corporation et al.
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Terry Leclair v. E. Sands & Associates
• Rafiki Properties Limited v. Integrated Housing Development Ltd.
• Doyle v. Gore Mutual Insurance Company et al.
• Khakh Enterprises Ltd. v. Western Union Insurance Company
• Dickson v. Hy's of Canada Ltd.
• Universal Printed Circuit Co., Canada v. Omni Graphics Ltd.
• Richmond Savings Credit Union v. Miller et al.
• Funk v. Dudar et al.
• Lec Engineering Ltd. et al. v. Sam and Agnel Holdings Ltd. et al.
• National Union Fire Insurance Company v. Trupin
• A.M.S. Equipment Inc. v. Case et al.
• Crosby et al. v. Native Fishing Association
• International Trademarks v. Clearly Canadian Beverage Corporation et al.
• In the Matter of the Notice of Intention to File a Proposal of Gene Moses Construction Ltd.
• Nethery v. Lindsey Morden Claim Services Ltd.
• Kwan v. Natingor et al.
• Remedicon-Remediation Consultants Ltd. v. A-1 Industrial Propane Ltd. et al.
• Venier v. Northern Telecom Limited
• In the Matter of the Bankruptcy of Lik Sang Paul Chung
• Peterco Holdings Ltd. v. Calverton Holdings Ltd. et al.
• Pineridge Capital Group Inc. et al. v. Anderson et al.
• Baird et al. v. Redell Mining Corp. et al.
• In the Matter of a Proposed Arrangement among Zarara Oil and Gas et al.
• M & P Logging v. Carrier Lumber et al
• Robinson v. ICBC
• Willow Fun World v. Directional Mining & Drilling
• Bankruptcies of Taylor Ventures et al
• Nobari v. Big 8 Management Consultants
• Re Gold Corp.
• Robinson v. ICBC
• Gill v. The Canada Life Assurance Company
• Riva Yachts of Canada Ltd. v. Dunfield et al.
• Cariboo Chryslet Inc. v. Ruff et al.